Friday, 12 April 2013


So Margaret Thatcher has passed away. Sorry but I do not understand all the parties celebrating her ultimate demise. She died the death of the wealthy. She lived a long enough life and was given the best of medical care to the end. She defied those who threatened her with a violent death and did indeed die in bed mourned by her surviving family.
She was a complex woman. She made history by becoming the first woman prime minister in the UK. She did so while coached by Saatchi and Saatchi into developing a more masculine gender identity. She did not make any significant impact on the feminist agenda and few women gained anything from her personal progress. She prayed St Francis’s prayer of peace and later sent the largest naval task force in supposed peace time to the South Atlantic in an act of unabashed violence. She did not create peace where there was discord.
She chose to privilege the banking sector over Britain's heavy industry. She did not count the social cost because she did not feel the need to recognise society. In the end she took jobs away from the working class and then adding insult to injury called them scroungers; indolent abusers of the welfare system. After all it was they who had held the country to ransom.
The banks were unfettered and allowed to act as they please. Today we pay the price of their incompetence while they claim undeserved bonuses. They hold the country to ransom now, deciding who will or will not receive credit for their business projects, choking those micro-enterprises begun by those trying to escape the clutches of the Job Centre.
Many clergy, especially of the Church of England saw her as someone who shifted the UK away from a culture of compassion to a culture of contempt where the virtue of solidarity was replaced with the ethic of success by any means.
I cannot join in the partying to celebrate her death. No, I cannot see any joy in her passing. She died the death of the wealthy and privileged, surrounded by medics and her family.
However, while many rush to bathe in her reflected glory, especially those of her party and the establishment it serves, we must not forget. To understand her true legacy we need to return to the end of her time in office. She herself recounted that, one by one, members of her cabinet filed into her office and told her that they could no longer support her as party leader. Her sense of betrayal was palpable. Once she had outlived her usefulness the party she led and the establishment it represented brushed her aside. She, like so many miners, shipbuilders, dockers and steel workers, was left redundant. The difference between the Iron lady and those whose lives and communities she had dismissed was that she was left utterly alone in pathetic isolation.  That was her legacy and no state funeral can wipe that away. It’s a funny old world………..

Wednesday, 16 November 2011

The Car Mechanic


There are times I see men coming to counselling with their partner and demand I rescue the relationship. I feel as though I am the car mechanic left to fix a beautiful Ferrari - the relationship - which has been thoroughly trashed.

I see him, in my mind’s eye, as someone who has been gifted the car by an indulgent father. He jumps in it and drives all around town showing it off. The thing is he can’t drive it properly; it is not broken in gently; there is no oil change. The paint work looks like it’s been washed with a wire pad for scrubbing old pans. The wing mirrors are smashed; the bumpers are dented and scratched due to incompetent and careless driving. The engine pistons have seized. I look and I could weep; what am I supposed to do?

The thing is that often men do actually look after their car more than they do their relationship; disturbing really!

The gift of counselling is that it helps us all; both men and women to become intentional about our intimate relationships. We can become clear about what it is that we do to each other already. We can identify what works and what doesn’t. We can talk and we can listen; and in that talking and listening we can make choices which enhance life and love; autonomy and authenticity.

So today can we make a choice?

Monday, 31 October 2011

Hallowe’en; Child’s Play


So here we are – Halloween that one night of the year when the dead, wizards and witches, and even the Elvin folk are let loose on us poor mortals. (Or is it that we let our imaginations loose on ourselves?) it is widely thought that Halloween originated as a pagan Celtic festival of the dead related to the Irish and Scottish harvest festival, Samhain, but there is no evidence that it was connected with the dead in pre-Christian times. It most probably marked the end of summer and the beginning of the darker half of the year. (Yes, the autumnal equinox happens a month earlier.) I wonder if it marked a pre-industrial revolution discomfort with the imposed darkness in which imaginations and fears ran riot. Does it reflect the reality of the not-so-good old days when infant mortality was so high, and average life expectancies were a half or even only a third of today’s luxurious longevity? Winter would have been a time when communities would have been purged of their weak and their sick. I can see why the scythe so prevalent in the harvest season would become a symbol associated with death at wintertime.

Of course Hallowe’en is the eve of All Hallows (All Saints) in the more Catholic faith traditions of Christianity. It is, again, when the faith community remembers those who have gone before and are now with God. The following day is All Souls when all the dead are remembered. This tends to be a much more personal remembrance for many.

Having lived and worked in Central America and spent so much time in the region, The Day of the Dead has left a deep impression on me. I have watched entire villages decant themselves to the cemetery and spending the entire day there tending graves with lavish decoration. In the more indigenous communities, Mayan priests would come and carry out their rites. The family would gather round their plots in the cemetery sharing stories and memories of those no longer present. The bells on the local church would toll calling out to the spirits to guide them home. A hole would be dug at the head of the grave and food and drink would be left there. The spirits of the loved ones would join in the feast consuming the spiritual essence of the meal. Then as the sun began to set the family would dig up the food and eat its material remains. After that they would go home, some quite content, others still bearing grief.

So what is Halloween to us today? Sometimes I wonder if it is a collective defence against the gnawing realisation that death still waits. Still, the shadow of our collective reality leaks into consciousness through nightmarish images. The comic partying is the joker within, taming our fears with mandatory laughter. Our consumer frenzy over the weekend collaborates in the distraction from the truth that will not be still.

When the party is over what remains? Can we face the truth?

Sunday, 23 October 2011

Eternal Love


The Christian belief that true love can never die is a beautiful one. That is why in Roman Catholic theology one cannot get a divorce. One must look for an annulment. This process recognises the end of a relationship but looks at why it never really was true love. There must have been something in the way from the start for it to fail. It is not that the love was necessarily absent, or bad. The idea is that it was wounded in the first place, or better, that it came from a wounded heart.

The problem with this belief is where the thing called love is actually possessiveness; where the relationship is an abusive one. Here, we have to admit that love is bad, so disfigured that it cannot truly be called love. Too often the promise of eternal love is interpreted by an abusive man as the unconditional possession of his property as an object. It is something over which he has total control; he may dispose of it as he wishes, including destruction or disfigurement. The problem with the idea of eternal love is that there is even the threat of an ex-lover waiting for you in the afterlife. Is that the truest definition of hell?

Perhaps the following is an alternative which allows us to avoid the threat of eternal love becoming hellish. Rather than offer undying love, we could offer love for as long as it is welcome. It would not be a conditional love but a love with a light non-possessive touch.

An alternative exchange of wedding vows

I know you and I know that you love me

And give yourself to me without reserve.

I accept this gift of yourself

And will honour and cherish it

For as long as it is mine.

I love you with all my heart

And I offer to share my life with you

And walk with you through times good and difficult.

I give my love to you without reserve

And I offer myself to you

For as long as my love is welcome

Sunday, 9 October 2011

Sweet Sixteen


I remember being a rather young fifteen year old when my friend told us that his girl friend was pregnant. He was the first friend of our group to discover he was to be a dad. In that group we were all of roughly the same age, he might have had a year on me. I always thought that he was really cool. (I felt pretty goofy compared to him.) Both he and his partner were trendy and sexy. They seemed to be all grown up and they had a sophistication about them. They let it be known that they were having sex. The theme still held that hungered mystique for me as one of the uninitiated. He always seemed to have an ease with alcohol that I had yet to acquire.

I was blown over by the news; it marked the radical discontinuity between childhood and adulthood. As lads we all celebrated his manhood realised. And yet very quickly he disappeared into the humdrum world of early nights, supper in front of the telly, nappies and bottles. He dropped out of sight as the mundane reality of a relationship and fatherhood took hold.

Both he and his partner seemed to leap from early adolescence into middle age in the blink of an eye. Looking back they seem to have been robbed of so much of the fun the rest of us went on to have. I lost contact with them at this point. Our lives took such different paths. I know that they split up a long time ago and each has had a number of relationships since. I have always wanted to ask what advice he would give to his younger self now. What might he want to say to his parents now that he is older than they were at that time?

It is a major question for Scotland today. After a decade of trying to reduce teen pregnancy we still have one of the highest teen pregnancy rates in Europe. It leads to single women trapped in poverty and a poor start in life for the children. It also often means that for the mother, and sometimes for the father premature closure to their development as adults, foreclosing the search for their authentic adult identity and a narrowing of horizons. For the man is can mean leaping from mother to (significant) other without becoming a rounded and truly independent adult. It does impact on the current relationship and can mean that the couple is not well equipped to tackle conflict and other stressors. In subsequent relationships, if the developmental challenges in the teen years are not revisited and surmounted, unsatisfying patterns of relating can become deeply embedded.

Saturday, 12 September 2009

Spiritual and Mental Well-being



Change and development
As the well worn saying goes: "we change to stay the same." In my opinion that simply reaffirms that the universe is governed by the fourth dimension, time. The whole of creation is in flux, driven by cycles of birthing and dying. That means that our holding environment is always changing. In order to maintain our place in that environment we too must change.
There are times we just automatically change; we are born, we grow, we diminish and we die. There is nothing we can do to change that. Even if despair at unending change overwhelms us and we take our own life, we are still victims of that final change. On the other hand we can also actively and deliberately participate in change . We make choices that determine the when and the what of change. That decision empowers us and makes us self-efficacious.
I don't believe that people change for the sake of change, other than perhaps fashion where one changes in order to maintain a certain social visibility. However, even here we are saying: "hey this is (the same) me!" As I see it the dynamic of change begins because of two triggers. The first is our capacity for interacting with the environment changes. In advanced years, that might mean going out for shorter walks in the winter. For an infant that might mean at last being able to walk. The second is where the environment changes; I am forced to go to school; my job becomes obsolete; a loved one dies. In these cases we simply can't go on as though nothing had changed. The environment demands a response from us, we change.
When we get stuck for whatever reason, the pain of change is too terrible, we have lost our life-bearings or our inner strength collapses, we find ourselves in trouble. We can get upset, or anxious, fear-filled or we just withdraw. Life looses its joy. It is at times like these we need an attentive ear to get oriented once again.
In the end I see the adventure of human life as a creation of God the Potter, working and reworking us from within and from without until at last this beautiful creation, that each of us is, finally satisfies the artist's eye.

Counselling Which Respects Your Faith Option



Often people tell us that when they go for therapy, they feel that their faith is seen as primitive or worse, part of their illness. Yes, there are times people express their mental illness through religious imagery etc, but that does not make religion a pathology. At Edinburgh Pastoral Counselling a person's faith is seen as their way of making sense out of the Big Picture. Faith does two very fundamental things for us; firstly it helps us to make meaning out of life. Secondly, it orients the way we relate to others in the light of the Other. Let me explain.

Meaning Making

We are always trying to make sense out of the things that are going on around us. Is this really it, or is there more? Each of us has a way of making meaning out of our experiences. We use them to orient our life's project and and give value to our life's project, what ever that may be. Many adopt the teaching of their faith community, parish, synagogue, mosque, temple. They use these teachings, often tailoring them to their own lives, to understand their personal story. And to a greater or lesser extent it works for them.

Christian counselling is a form of counselling based on the science of psychology and the art of counselling based on specifically Christian teaching. That teaching, including its institutions and rites is a very strong prism through which the counsellor sees the client. This can cause problems where the counsellor is unable to bracket and put to one side certain teachings. These are very important when looking at issues such as sexual orientation, divorce and the termination of a pregnancy. Please don't get me wrong, there are many who do work in these areas and offer a sterling service. All the same it is important to know where your core values and your counsellor's core values resonate and where they clash.

Biblical Counselling is a form of counselling where the counsellor is really highly directive and aiming at changing the counselee in order to conform to their Church's interpretation of biblical teaching and ethics. It is an extremely controversial form of counselling because of its strong moralistic tone. It can often confuse sin with mental health. Much of its base is actually pre-modern and hence pre-scientific. In the wrong hands it can interpret an experience of multiple personalities as possession by evil spirits rather than disassociative identity disorder. To do so will cause great harm to the client. Many of us believe that to be gross misconduct.

Pastoral Counselling began in the middle of the last century. It grew out of a concern by liberal reformed pastors in the US. They saw a need for a counselling approach which would be theologically informed as well as psychologically informed. It was not simply a refusal to look down on the religious interpretation of human experience and behaviour as was the case in psychotherapy at the time. Rather these pastors saw that theological reflection on the client's personal spiritual experience lead to a richer interpretation of life in the concrete. It gave much needed depth to the client's self-understanding. Pastoral Counselling is the care of the whole person seeing him or her as a thinking, feeling behaving human being and also as an incarnate spirit living in a relationship with God. It is founded on two cultural sources, one the Judeo-Christian-Islamic tradition of the One God who reveals the Divine Self to us and so invites us into relationship. The second is the modern science of psychology.

Living in Relationship

So rather than begin with Church teaching or the Bible, pastoral counselling uses theology to reflect on the meaning of the client's life and his or her relationships. How we relate to others and how we relate to God, the absolute Other, influence one another in the most profound manner. As Chief Seattle says we are all connected in an intimate web of relationship to one another and to creation itself. The love or contempt with which we treat one another is the love or contempt we heap upon God. In the counselling room we look at ourselves as thinking, feeling, behaving people and how we relate to the personal world we live in. So we want to transform our self-understanding in order to be more fully the man, the woman, God dreams we will become.

Finding Hope

Hope is all about holding together the things we really care about in life in the face of life's knocks. It is more than just optimism which is a bright and positive way of seeing things. Hope is not how we see things; it is much more. Really, it is a virtue or an energy which gives us the strength to move forward in life with purpose. The closer that purpose fits out ideals and values, the more faithful we are to God's dream for us.

In the end hope has us believe that God is on our side and that God stands in our future drawing us to God's future. So our own story makes sense even in the midst of pain and suffering. Our hope empowers us and makes us efficacious in the struggle to fulfill our own dreams.